
There’s a moment about five seconds later Michael As the artist’s familiar “hee-hee” blares and the Michael Jackson estate logo flashes across the screen. It’s a small thing, but it tells you a lot. Before the film begins, it quietly draws a line about what the story will and won’t be.
I kept thinking about this as the film progressed, not because I was expecting any kind of exposition (I wasn’t), but because even within its own carefully chosen confines, the film is strangely uninterested in exploring the psyche of the man at its center.
Sketches of childhood, but unintelligible
The film opens in 1966 in Gary, Indiana with a young man Michael Jackson already allocated. He watches from the window as children his age play outside in the snow, while he stays with his brothers at rehearsals under the stern eye of their father, Joseph. It is a strong image. You will immediately get what director Antoine Fuqua Intending: Michael as a weirdo, a wonder who doesn’t quite belong.
But the film stops there. It doesn’t push the “why” of this isolation. Her mother Catherine’s faith as a devout Jehovah’s Witness, which could have deepened her sense of distance, hardly accounts for it. We have instead something simpler and more subtle: he is special, no one but his family understands him, so he is alone.
Of course, there are some more grounded flashes. Coleman DomingoJoseph Jackson is rough, sometimes scary, defined by belt, abuse, constant pressure to win. The abuse isn’t hidden, and you can see how it can shape Michael’s sense of self—the fixation on his appearance, his need for control, his fear of failure. But even here, the film makes Joseph look a bit bland. He’s less human than a concerted villain. Domingo tries to find something human in him, but the writing does not meet him halfway.
More peaceful moments Nia Long As a matriarch, Katherine is getting closer to landing. There’s a softness to these scenes, a sense of someone trying to keep the family together without fully confronting what’s going on in it. For several minutes, the film breathes. Then he moves on.

By-the-Numbers Biopic that Plays Like a List
And boy, does it really keep moving. Years pass in minutes. The Jackson 5 finally broke through. Motown comes calling. Gord the monk He especially sees potential in young Michael, who he says sings “Who’s Lovin’ You” better Smokey Robinson ever did Suddenly we’re in Encino, then in the solo years, then behind the wallthen Thriller. It becomes a blur of stages, each one folding before it has time to land. The structure is chronological, but does not build. It just piles one moment on top of another.
This pacing could work if the film had a strong point of view. Instead, it often feels like it’s setting up a highlight reel rather than a proper story. The music carries him as expected. You can’t deny the appeal of these songs – these songs still hit. But the problem is everything around them. John LoganThe script features scenes that are like fillers between performances Quincy Jones Probably there would be a problem.
Jafar Jacksonwho plays the uncle as an adult, is one of the few reasons the film remains watchable at all. He has physicality—movements, voice, small gestures—and there are moments when something flashes, especially quietly, when he’s not asked to simply repeat what we already know. You have a feeling of insecurity, of weakness under performance. Giuliano Krue Wald Michael Jr. is also doing well. But both performances feel restrained. They can only go when the film refuses to delve deeper.
The film traces Michael’s arrested development—his closeness to animals, his dependence on protection, the sense that his world is getting smaller even as his fame grows—but he never stays long enough to explore it. There is sadness there, or at least the outline of one. Then the movie stops.

There is music. It doesn’t matter
The same thing happens with the music, and this is where the film started to lose me.
For a film about one of the most detail-oriented artists in pop history, it’s no surprise that this music was actually made. Songs are used to signal emotional or artistic growth, but the choice isn’t always there. “Human Nature” plays in a moment meant to reflect his deepening perspective as he sees gang violence dominating the local news, even though he didn’t write it. “I Can’t Help It” is used similarly. This may be a minor detail for most people, but for me it’s not just a minor detail. They bridge the gap between performer and creator, which is important when you’re telling the story of someone like Michael Jackson.
Then there is Thriller. The film builds towards it, celebrates it… and just keeps going. Rod Tempertonwho wrote the title track and who also featured in it behind the wallIt is barely recognized beyond a passing mention. Musicians who helped shape the sound of the album – members of Toto, Eddie Van Halen– Do not register at all. This makes the collaborative process seem strangely solitary, which is at odds with the reality of how this music came together.
At a certain point it becomes clear what the film is more comfortable doing: recreating moments we already know. Motown 25 performance. The making of “Beat It”. Pepsi commercial crash. They are all here, cleanly staged, sometimes energetically. But little is known about their performance.

“Michael”: a concert film in disguise
This also applies to the overall shape of the film. very often Michael It feels like a concert film trying to pass itself off as biographical. The performance sequence has energy but drags out the rest. John Ottmanwhich worked Bohemian RhapsodyIs part of the editing team here and you can feel the same push and pull. When the music plays, the movie moves. When it doesn’t, the pacing slackens and the scenes feel like placeholders.
The casting choice doesn’t always help either. Miles Teller Appears as a John Cusack– looks John Branca For a few scenes, it delivers basic exposition and fades out. It’s a role that anyone could play. Bringing in a recognizable actor for something so thin ends up being less of a creative decision and more of a marketing one.
None of them feel neglected, exactly. If anything, it feels overly cautious. You can sense that Fuqua has a lot of respect for Michael Jackson. To be honest, I felt the film was made with love. He wants to honor the man’s legacy. But that respect turns into caution, and that caution keeps the film from taking any real risks.
The importance of visual language to the central character
Which begs the bigger question: Was Fuqua the right filmmaker for this? Maybe it’s subjective. But when you think about someone like that Baz Luhrmann And what did he bring? Elvis– The style, the exuberance, the sense of scale – it’s hard not to feel that this story needed a stronger visual voice. Michael Jackson was not just a performer. He was an architect of icon and sound. The film made about him should reflect that. It just isn’t.
Finally, there is an absence that lies above everything that warrants the emergence of heavy discourse. The film ends in the late 80s, before the most difficult chapters of Jackson’s life begin. I understand the legal reality. I also understand the argument that a film can choose its scope. But it doesn’t look like a deliberate frame choice. It feels like an avoidance, not only of accusations, but of anything that might complicate the image the film is trying to maintain.
I can see an argument that maybe we should see the film where it stands, that it’s meant to be a simplified, accessible version of the story, something closer to a celebration than an interrogation. Fair enough. But even by that standard, it falls short. Like a movie I’m not there (Bob Dylan) or love and mercy (Brian Wilson) does not represent only the life of the artist; He finds a way into it, technically or emotionally. unfortunately Michael It never quite goes there.

A serviceable, but ultimately disappointing, middling biopic
As a musical experience, Michael Works great. Hearing these songs again, putting them on the big screen, is still a rush. It’s hard to resist. But once the music fades away, there’s nothing left to hold on to.
And maybe that’s what makes it frustrating. It’s a story that could have gone either way: messy, contradictory, unresolved. Instead, it settles for something safe and pre-approved, something that distances you from the person it’s about.
I grew up with this music. Many did. Which frustrates me Michael landed a little harder. Not because the film avoids certain things, but because it barely cares to say anything new.
