cDespite the popularity of his music and the interest of streaming services in faith-based programming, I’m always a little surprised that there aren’t more movies and TV shows about Nashville. Anyway, the idea of Nashville, the mecca of country music, constantly struggling to define itself within and against the country, a place that has always been more diverse than its reputation, but still clings to a certain image of white, Christian American. Mine has many enduring objections—hypermasculine men singing their hearts out, a Madonna complex among her relatively few female stars, suburban money in a genre that seems to speak to the common man in the countryside.
Netflix seems to be aiming for some difficulty with Heartland , a slick neo-noir thriller starring Jessica Chastain as a washed-up ex-starlet with an ax to grind as a vigilante-turned-detective on Music Row. Chastain’s Misty Jones is certainly the prickly Nashville archetype, a female lead we might call “unlovable,” drawn from the sharp point of view of a bad country song (said lovingly by someone who grew up on country radio). The first five minutes of the nearly two-hour film by Shana Feste, the writer-director perhaps best known for the 2010 film Country Strong, which launched Gwyneth Paltrow’s short-lived singing career. A haunting echo of better days past (in this case, Grammy in an empty fridge that feels inspired in its rawness).
Shameless and boisterous, but full of torment, capable of crying and holding a gun at you in 10 seconds, Misty, we are told by every character who comes into contact with her – lest the unwary viewers miss the first mention – is a renegade work. He’s long been isolated on a farm in Georgia, for almost parodic reasons, having abruptly left Nashville 20 years ago, an era the characters talk about as if it were the past, the rustic past, and not yet within Taylor Swift’s career. (The Bluebird Cafe, the launch site for Swift’s country record deal, as well as many others, is welcome, one of several Nashville institutions that gives the Heartland the rare sense of a spot for Netflix.)
But for all of Misty’s fiery resistance—and Chastain plays her like a renegade vibrating with vengeance—she’s drawn back into the scene when her estranged brother (Paul Sparks) seeks help: her niece, the suspiciously named Charlie Hart (Georgian singer Carter Faith), a 22-year-old in Nashville who owns her. He left his mark on the CBS pilot in Sherdan’s verse: a potential stalker, an old record book, a suspiciously smug former fellow blonde singer Jaycee (Ross Lynch), a mustachioed manager in Roy Combs (Garrett Hedlund), whose charisma and Vacil.
Although it seems to be aiming for the Southern Gothic and antihero chic of HBO’s Sharp Objects , Heartland is thankfully not an eight-part series and continues to hit the dirt road at a rough clip; I abide by Netflix’s spoiler alert, but a sharp early turn that can be seen from a country mile unfortunately pushes the film down a more generic path. At times, Misty’s amateur detective work and return to the scene—a soundtrack of country hits, reverse-engineered and at least performed in real venues—falls on the side of country music’s Big Green Tractor: treating “real America” so blandly that it’s hard to resist. The affected accents and dead-serious clangers (“There are no good girls,” Misty spits) can be intoxicating in their directness; The whiskey-drinking scenes in dive bars, accompanied by some actual scenes on a live stage (Channing Wilson singing Alan Jackson’s Tall, Tall Trees) give the film a more distinct flavor than its live streaming brethren.
But mostly, and especially in the lackluster final act, which is distinguished only by the benevolent presence of Sugarland’s Jennifer Nettles, Heartland struggles to keep a pulse. It’s not for lack of effort; With every tearful, Chastain tries to overshadow Misty’s pain with her over-the-top gun persona and historical plot twists. But while he fulfills the major movie star requirement of being the one to watch every scene, his tenacity reads like borderline camp when surrounded by such nonsense. To be fair, there’s something cute and country-like about the space between the smiley and the serious. But Heartland is meant more for background music than a hit.