(Editor’s note: This review was originally published on September 5, 2026 during the 2026 Telluride Film Festival. Focus Features will release the film in theaters on Friday, November 20.)
There is no doubt that Andrew Scott, the 49-year-old Irish actor, has earned his place as one of the best modern actors. He’s in demand, but he chooses wisely, and in roles that slyly subvert his status as an out gay man (a rare thing to be sure), but something under the dime, often a secret. He played Tom Ripley, more sociopathic than Matt Damon’s calculating Adonis, to devastating effect in the villainous Netflix series Ripley, where he more openly grappled with Patricia Highsmith’s character’s ambiguous (but was?) sexuality. He played a hot priest who rejected heterosexual, secular love in “Fleabag,” of course, and starred in “All of Us Strangers” as a lonely grown-up orphan living in a glittering tower preparing for romantic intimacy with Paul Mescal.
I also saw her perform nine roles in Anton Chekhov’s Vanya on stage last year in New York as all kinds of men and women, showing an actor capable of gender and range. He has an unwavering warmth about who you should trust, but with the intrigue behind the scenes of many of his performances suggesting you might not. He is so good.
Scott has now taken what I believe will be the “role of a lifetime” at this point in director Simon Stone’s sad, poignant and extraordinary new drama Elsinore, as Scottish actor Ian Charlson, who died of complications from HIV/AIDS while portraying Hamlet at London’s National Theatre. along with Even the most public of the dead still lurk among the most publicly gay, though Charlson himself was not out. He resisted pressure from his inner circle to reveal his illness amid a stage that miraculously lasted 24 performances. At that time, actors were afraid of tarnishing their reputation. It’s not so different now, even though many advances have made HIV/AIDS locally feel like a plague of the past.
The blond Scott gives a valiant performance as Charlson with the urgency and commitment of any of his best work, but that’s not the problem: it’s that the film around him detracts from the greatness of his performance with its conventional plotting and overcomplication in post. “Elsinore” is one of those movies where you can sense that the filmmaker — here, Stone, known for both stage and screen — is actively working to “open the play” to the possibilities of cinema. But “Elsinore” was never a play. Instead, this is a film where every emotional punch is worth it, especially Charlson’s swan song performance as Hamlet, reduced to a frenetic montage of editing that doesn’t allow the material to breathe. Or the audience sinks.
Charlson played an Olympic athlete in 1981’s Best Picture winner Chariots of Fire and an Anglican priest in the following year’s Best Picture topper Gandhi. This was after playing an extreme bisexual in the 1978 film Jubilee, directed by her former lover, the very openly gay director Derek Jarman, who died of AIDS in 1994. In addition to several films, including in “Elsinore” as in “Elsinore” as Dario Argento on stage. At one point in this film, Scotty Charlson reflects on how much more satisfying stage work is for an actor without an editor to cut you to pieces.
Stone, working from a script by Stephen Beresford (himself a playwright), doesn’t follow his hero’s example. Every thoughtful examination of Kaposi’s sarcoma lesions, or buckets of blood under the watchful eye of conscientious practitioner Dr. Margaret Johnson (Olivia Colman) to show the grim reality of the disease, is captured in a feature-length trailer. The best scenes from the production of “Hamlet,” detailed near the end of the film, are relegated to a rushed montage that doesn’t give us a sense of what we’re promised is a tremendous performance. (The 1990 production was directed by Richard Eyre, later a filmmaker such as the campaign diva battle “Notes on Scandal.” He starred in Johnny Flynn’s “Elsinore”.)
Several things happen: “Elsinore” evokes in the sensibilities of a sober gay audience the signifiers of what an AIDS-bait movie of serious gravity would be. Tom Hanks’ Oscar-winning performance in the movie “Philadelphia”. Ed Harris in The Hours. Everyone who came out of the miserable “Dallas Buyers Club” at the 2014 Oscars. There are others, although they lost more time. We are jealous of this device, especially when combined with excellent acting. Is HIV/AIDS Exploitation in the Package of a Presumptive Oscar Hit? Or do we show a young queer audience what it was like, how we got to where we are, and what it’s like where it’s still not perfect? It can be both, but the structure of “Elsinore” goes to the first.
Set in the theoretically irresistible but often helpless setting of London’s Elsinore in 1989 is a veritable, cheeky who’s who of British literary figures and luminaries. There’s Eyre, of course, and Jarman (David Dawson, as fine and tender and wounded here as he was in his screen breakthrough in My Cop). However, the afterburn from her relationship with Charlson remains palpable. After a few drinks, she invites Charlson home, but instead they part in one of those silent kisses shared by people who once loved each other but can’t do it anymore. There is so much history here. Charlson’s secret relationships and extended friendships with various (and outside) men make up the best parts of “Elsinore,” but there’s no life. (Joe Locke plays a young man who is also sick at Johnson’s AIDS clinic with Charlson.)
The pale grays of Mike Ely’s cinematography may mimic the end of HIV/AIDS, but there’s no aesthetic passion to balance what becomes an absolute misery to watch on screen. I’m not one to compare one gay social drama to another, but Robin Campillo’s 2017 Cannes-winning French drama Beats Per Minute captured such warmth and drama in a more activist-oriented story about ACT UP’s fight against AIDS suppression in Paris. Watching a room die of AIDS becomes boring unless someone is given a reason to go on living.
The reason for this, of course, must be Charlson’s performance in Hamlet, which ended in a stormy scene at the end of the film, after many painful rehearsals, in which he refused to perform (and in which Jonson encouraged him). Scott has a mesmerizing power in his scenes, and he’s compelling to watch alongside Coleman as Johnson, who was treating the disease at a time when it was most stigmatized. He named his new HIV testing clinic after her; It was he who influenced her. We are told how much Charlson meant to the people, but never shown. Which unfortunately divides “Elsinore,” the Danish town where “Hamlet” was filmed and where its main character died, into the realm of HIV/AIDS films that seek prestige over deep feelings.
Grade: C
“Elsinore” premiered at the 2026 Telluride Film Festival. Focus Features will release it on November 20.

