There are documentaries that are more than just movies; They are sensory experiences. Perhaps they belong more in the realm of museum art installations, or should be experienced in a multi-sensory environment. In a way, it’s almost a shame that they experience it through a screen instead. When faced with projects like this, it is very difficult to offer a critical assessment that includes everything one feels when looking at their images. It is difficult to talk about them and convey these sensations in words, because it is just as difficult for the reader to convey the physical sensation that moves through the gaze, so to speak.
This, of course, is a problem facing film criticism in general. Perhaps not the problem, but the challenge: finding a way to put these feelings into words. Words that immediately come to mind when thinking Concrete turned to sand Fascinating, ethereal and mysterious, of course, but also somewhat melancholic and, above all, mundane. Indeed, despite getting lost in the breathtaking images of this work by Canadian directors Jessica Johnson and Ryan Ermacora.
The 73-minute film premiered in its home country at Hot Docs and Vancouver’s DOXA festival. It follows a collective of oyster farmers on Corte Island, British Columbia, in their daily encounters with the transitional landscape, examining the gradual transformations caused by ocean warming and acidification, and observing how these shifts are recorded at ecological, temporal, and geographic scales. Presenting the different stages of growing and harvesting oysters, the camera captures the rhythm and complexity of the workers’ daily activities, even if it leaves much of the process unexplained.

Showing rather than telling
The only risk in this otherwise outstanding work is that whatever it conveys through imagery, it says relatively little. The lack of dialogue may strike some viewers as a drawback, but given the subject matter, it could be a strength; Others may find the film paradoxically shallow. Explanations are not entirely lacking, and at times even overly technical, so the balance between contemplation and explanation is maintained quite well, even if the reality portrayed remains unclear from time to time. The film offers an eye-opening look at the stages of growing and harvesting oysters, capturing the rhythm and intricacies of the workers’ daily routine, but we remain observers, outside the ritual. Whether this distance is a drawback or an encouraging choice is perhaps up to the viewer.
The two directors do an interesting job precisely because of this: they manage to strike an emotional chord with the audience, not by explaining the situation in a didactic or overly explicit way, but by allowing the audience to enter and experience a life that undergoes a transformation that is not imposed due to adverse environmental conditions. In this sense, their approach may represent another standard or model for creating informative, educational documentaries on environmental issues.

“Sunlights vary, but there is only one darkness”
Ursula K. Le Guin’s opening quote is particularly emblematic, and his last line is worth highlighting because the film is built on the duality between light and dark. The 35mm look (in its unmistakable square 1.33:1 frame) really brings the story to life, and Jeremy Cox’s cinematography is what really sets this work apart. His cinematography is particularly striking, playing with the contrast between the visible and the hidden in the dark, something Cox had already explored in Acknowledged. rooms. Its color palette relies on blues as well as greens, which enhance the extraordinary visual effects of the film and create a sense of suspended reality that envelops the viewer. Through this beautifully orchestrated look, rather than approaching the changing environment as a distant phenomenon, it observes the intimate relationships between the ocean, the land, and the people whose livelihoods depend on them.
Concrete turned to sand is a challenging documentary in its viewing experience, precisely because it departs from more traditional forms of educational and informative documentary cinema. However, as a result, it can offer a new way of looking at things, generating enthusiasm and interest. Ultimately, what is important in documentary filmmaking is the constant pursuit of innovation and the search for a balance between story and visual experience. In this case, the visual experience takes precedence, tipping the balance in its favor. Nevertheless, it represents a choice that can certainly be described as bold and daring, and perhaps even somewhat necessary.
The post Concrete turned to sand appeared first on Modern Times Review.