...

Is the DC Cinematic Universe just cursed?

Hell of a way to start the news week, Captain? Just over a month after Paramount Skydance’s Warner Bros. With the acquisition of Discovery complete, we have news about James Gunn and Peter Safran. they come out As the heads of DC Studios. Whether you’ve been a fan of Gunn’s approach to DC heroes or not, announcing a whole slew of movies and TV series to be forced out after only four years with several projects halfway through development is a hell of a way to end it all. While we don’t know if the DCU will continue or be rebooted under new head Jeremy Latcham (Gun is apparently still attached to write another DC project after the release of his Superman sequel Man of Tomorrow), the shakeup suggests that Gunn’s plans won’t survive in their current form.

Considering how many times DC’s cinematic strategy has changed over the past decade, I can’t help but ask: Is the DC Cinematic Universe simply cursed? Will we ever see a stable version of the DC universe on the big screen, or will it forever live in the MCU’s shadow? Let’s go in.

zero hour

When Gunn and Safran took control of DC Studios, there was no denying that the franchise was in the doldrums. The first Wonder Woman and Aquaman films may have been financially successful, but Zack Snyder and Joss Whedon’s clashing visions for Justice League made the series’ main line a train wreck that fueled subsequent projects. This led to a string of films that were all box office disappointments or outright failures, including Birds of Prey, Black Adam, Shazam! Wrath of the Gods, Flash and Blue Beetle. There have been so many failures in a row that it’s hard to rationalize how the brand managed to stay alive.

Gunn’s entry was seen by many as a much-needed injection of fresh blood, even if he already had DC experience with The Suicide Squad and the Peacemaker spin-off series. He’s off to a strong start with the Superman reboot, which isn’t perfect, but gets the basics right with a good cast, an upbeat tone, and Fantastic reception A poem about Lex Luthor. Still, Gunn’s idiosyncracies came back to bite him; His love of C-list characters and unrelenting quirkiness led to backlash from fans who wondered why he was developing projects on Gorilla Grodd and Krypto while major heroes like Batman and Wonder Woman were nowhere to be seen. The reveal, which discussed a Polka-Dot Man prequel show shortly before this week’s news, is hard not to read as humorously ironic.

null
James Gunn

However you feel about Gunn’s DC output, the biggest knock against him was that he had already done projects in the previous DCEU, making it difficult to analyze the new DCU canon. Warners wanted to reboot the franchise, but Gunn was never going to throw out his own film continuity, or get rid of actors he personally liked (or was married to). It was hard for me to roll my eyes when we learned that “aspects” of the Suicide Squad and the Peacemaker were canon to the DCU while the rest of the DCEU were banished from continuity. And Gunn had to “Is It Canon?” podcast to clarify an issue about his own work that has led to outlandish statements like his Not sure Does the Joker exist in the DCU, but at the same time he said that Margot Robbie was welcome to reprise her role as Harley Quinn if she wanted to.

At the end of the day, most of Gunn’s plans for DC will never see fruition. He launched this venture with a hugely ambitious (and now we know, overly presumptuous) “Chapter One” plan that included 10 film and television projects, more than half of which were either canceled or plunged into development hell when the shakeup was announced. It’s a sad state of affairs, but unfortunately for DC, hardly unprecedented.

Royal fashion

Comic book fans hoped that Gunn’s vision for the DCU would help the Justice League and their friends from the constant conflict of previous adaptations. Instead, the DCU repeated the pattern of rebellion and second-guessing that went all the way back to 2013’s Man of Steel . Zack Snyder’s conception of Superman was polarizing to say the least, aiming to launch a competitor in the Marvel Cinematic Universe, which many viewers derided for its villainous and violent heroes (DC).However, he certainly had his fans as well). This situation was only made worse by the disastrous reception of Batman v Superman: Dawn of Justice, whose critical and audience reception left the DCEU in a ditch, while the MCU soared to new heights. Like Gunn, Snyder’s plan was ambitious A five-film arc Which was supposed to include three Justice League movies, only to crater halfway through production when the studio hired Joss Whedon to direct and remix the first Justice League movie.

Zack Snyder’s DC plans fell apart after BATMAN V SUPERMAN.

The rest is history: Justice League came and went as little more than a wave of superhero movies, its only significant relevance to the franchise being how much Snyder’s loyalists clamored for it before accepting its four-hour assembly cut in 2021. The next gambit was a series reboot, a Flash movie reboot, a Flashpoint adaptation. About the DCEU. But The Flash itself became another headache with a revolving door of directors and writers attached to the project, including Seth Grahame-Smith, Rick Famuyiwa and John Francis Dale and Jonathan Goldstein, before Andy Muschietti finally crossed the finish line. That’s not even getting into how the film’s release became a public relations nightmare when lead actor Ezra Miller went cross-state. A crime spree And the third act committed some silly CGI necromanticism to dead actors like Christopher Reeve, Adam West and George Reeves.

The amount of DCEU knowledge behind the scenes is frankly impressive. One of the biggest movie studios on Earth (before they were absorbed into the Skydance conglomerate) continued to create blockbuster family entertainment franchises in situations like CEO Kevin Tsujihara, who resigned in 2019 after being caught soliciting. sexual favors Cyborg actor Ray Fisher in exchange for acting work from actress Charlotte Kirk accusation Whedon and DC’s corporate leadership, including Tsujihara’s replacement Walter Hamada, for creating a hostile and racist work environment, and Dwayne “The Rock” Johnson. leaking Falsified financial information to the press to deceive people that Black Adam was not a box office bomb. The latter tried to get Johnson to take advantage of the power vacuum before Gunn’s hiring ended with Henry Cavill returning as Superman in a Black Adam post-credits scene, only for Cavill to publicly introduce himself as Superman once again. leaving the role after two months.

The amount of DCEU knowledge behind the scenes is frankly impressive.“

With all of this and how many DCEU movies have been announced and subsequently canceled (RIP Ben Affleck’s solo Batman movie), is it really any wonder that DC’s cinematic universe has never come close to the same cultural resonance as Marvel’s? But now that we know another leadership change is coming, the biggest question looming on the other side of Gunn’s tenure is: Will the next era be different?

What will happen to tomorrow’s man?

The next major release for the DCU is Gunn’s Superman sequel, Man of Tomorrow. The director will remain on the project through post-production, but with Latcham taking over as head of DC films, what was once supposed to be a mainstay of Gunn’s universe will now be glorified. Just as Flash finished a Disappointing finale For the DCEU, fans now go into Man of Tomorrow knowing it’s the end of Gunn’s vision for the DCU instead of what he originally intended. The constant shuffling of leadership means that, like The Flash before it, The Man of Tomorrow is all about creating new characters and storylines after we already know they’re not going anywhere. What’s the point of investing in DC’s attempts at ongoing continuity if they’re just going to be reset and retooled in a few years, assuming they’re not completely canceled like Leslie Grace’s ill-fated Batgirl movie?

James Gunn’s Man of Tomorrow: Superman vs. Lex Luthor Art Gallery

To be fair, it’s possible that Latcham will continue the current DCU and not force us to reboot yet again. IGN’s Jesse Schedin made the argument that it would be a mistake to kick Gunn’s universe out given how recently we finished the last version. But new leadership rarely acts without ideas of its own, which means the fate of Gunn’s characters is up in the air. Will DC really accommodate the death of Kyle Chandler’s Hal Jordan if they want to revive the Green Lantern franchise? Will Tom Rhys Harry’s Clayface meet the next incarnation of Batman? What if Latcham’s next round of hired talent has their own casting ideas for characters already cast by Gunn, such as Adria Ariona rumored to be taking on the role of Wonder Woman in Man of Tomorrow ? Lucky for them, Goon hasn’t cast his brother Shawn as the Joker yet!

This, of course, brings up another argument that has been made over the years: that fans and the press need to stop treating superhero projects as parts of a larger universe and instead as individual works. I get the idea, I get it, but the flaw in this thinking is that it isn’t thoughtful As individual projects already. Since the success of the MCU, virtually every superhero adaptation has been produced and marketed as chapters in a broader franchise, whether it’s Sony’s supervillain spin-offs, their Spider-Verse projects, or the DCU. Even stand-alone films like Matt Reeves’ Batman continue to be part of the same cinematic universe experiment, with spin-offs like The Penguin Show on HBO Max being billed as “Batman’s epic crime saga.” Moviegoers watching The Man of Tomorrow are being asked to turn off the part of their brain that knows a lot about what Gunn is developing inside of him can be changed, thereby leading people to believe that they aren’t actually deserving.

We’ll see where DC goes next as the last remnants of Gunn’s reign are dealt with. But if DC ever wants to avoid being a runner-up, they need to understand that constant churning has poisoned audience goodwill. After all, it’s impossible to build anything solid when the foundation is always crumbling beneath you.

Carlos Morales has been writing about science fiction and comics since 2019 and has read over 10,000 comics. You can follow his fixation Twitter.

Leave a Comment