...

Our Salvation by Emmanuel Marais, Weak

Emmanuel Marais our salvation has a genuinely unsettling premise of casual complicity, but bogs down the two-and-a-half-hour bureaucratic drudgery that misses the accumulation of depth. ★★☆☆☆

Seen at its world premiere in competition at the Cannes Film Festival, Emmanuel Marais’ second feature, Notre Salute (a man of his time), A premise emerges that should carry considerable weight: a fictional account of the director’s own grandfather, a failed engineer, who speaks fluently in the Vichy bureaucracy in September 1940. Raw has potential and is genuinely disturbing, not because Henri Marais is a monster, but because he isn’t. He is a mediocre man with grandiose self-awareness and limited talent, who sees the new order not as an ideology he believes in, but as a ladder he can climb. This is a far more disturbing portrait than any depiction of bigotry.

After all, the tragedy of Vichy was not that it was built only by true believers, but that it was guarded by men like Henry: opportunists and self-deceivers. The problem is that Mare, the film director, can never decide what to do with Mare, the great grandfather. In the 155 minutes of the film, mostly men talk in closed rooms. A format that has produced some of cinema’s greatest works, but one that requires the pressure to build, the feeling that every conversation is turning the screws. Here the conversations are gathered without building. Bureaucratic rhythms, which are supposed to evoke the banality of cooperation, instead become the epitome of banality and tedium.

our salvation? I’m bored and I can’t stand it

Swan Arlo, who has established a reputation in recent years as one of French cinema’s most quietly compelling performances, does what he can with Henri. His sad eyes and wavering manner suggest that the man is constantly convincing himself that what he is doing is reasonable, even admirable. However, the film never finds a perspective on its subject that would make Henri’s ordinariness interesting. We watch him maneuver, prevaricate, and justify himself, but to little effect. The screenplay, based on letters exchanged between the director’s grandparents, is so faithful to the source material that it forgets to turn it into a drama.

A Man of His Time (Notre Salute)
Swan Arlo and Sandrine Blanc in Notre Salute (A Man of His Time)

Sandrine Blanc, as Henri’s wife Paulette, gets the clearest emotional line in the film as a woman who watches her husband’s moral collapse with increasing insight and waning patience. He’s quietly devastating in a role that the film unfortunately continues to make its way to the margins, as if the more interesting perspective of Henri’s story was somehow sidelined.

The cinematography offers no compensating enjoyment. Olivier Boonjing’s images are competent but largely anonymous, content to document the proceedings in the actual Vichy administrative locations where filming took place, a decision that clearly cost something in terms of production logistics, but yields surprisingly little in terms of atmosphere. Rooms are like rooms. Corridors are like corridors. One is constantly waiting for the camera to find the angle that frames the material, forcing the visual grammar to do some interpretive work. This never happens.

Anachronistic musical cues, the film’s most discussed formal gesture, appear like elbows in the ribs. The aim is, presumably, to jolt the audience out of the comfort of period drama, to remind us that the ideological currents running through Vichy France did not end politely in 1944. First, this idea is hardly new and has been repeated by people who don’t know what fascism is. In our salvation The idea never rises above the level of gimmicks, a shortcut that hints at the irony that the film didn’t win with its drama and doesn’t need to, given that the theme provides all the discomfort it needs. Such a stylistic choice would require a far more accomplished director than Marais.

Notre Salute stage in the open air.
Our Salvation by Emmanuel Marais.

Marais is clearly sincere about the material, which makes the film’s failure all the more disappointing. The Vichy period is not lacking in cinematic treatment, Dan Sad and sad that Goodbye children; It produced France’s most searching self-examination, and Marais’s instinct to approach it in the mundane rather than the dramatic is correct. Good Intentions, however, is not a compelling film and its considerable length, A man of his time He mistakes seriousness for rigor, accumulation for depth. The subject matter deserved a sharper film. Maybe Swan Arlod did too. This is another film that documents the deep crisis that plagues contemporary French cinema.

our salvation won the award for best screenplay, which may sound strange, but this year the competition was extremely weak. At least Marais’ film had more substance than the disastrous film that won the same award two years ago.

Leave a Comment