The Tallinn Black Nights Film Festival, known as PÖFF, marks its 30th edition from 6 to 22 November, with screenings in Tallinn and Tartu. Founded in 1997 as a showcase for Nordic cinema, it has grown into the only FIAPF-accredited competitive feature film festival in Northern Europe, and its industry programme fills the Estonian capital with film professionals each autumn. Documentaries have long found their way onto the schedule, yet until 2024 they arrived without a competition of their own. Doc@PÖFF changed that, and in 2025 it divided into an International Competition and a Baltic Competition. This year the two strands hold eleven and nine films respectively, and the anniversary edition also hosts the World Congress of Science and Factual Producers in Tallinn from 9 to 12 November.
Marianna Kaat has led the documentary programming since the start. An Estonian documentary director and producer who teaches at Tallinn University, she made The Last Relic, which premiered at Hot Docs in 2023, and now works with three fellow programmers who watch films over the summer and debate them once a week. In this interview, she describes assembling the International Competition after six chosen films went elsewhere, and the surprising approach to reality she found running through those that remained.
«The life of a documentary is short»
PÖFF screens far more than documentaries. How did you approach building the International Competition, and where does curating sit within your wider career?
For the International Competition, we need world premieres. All the films except one are world premieres, and that one is an international premiere. We are only in our third year with documentary, even though the festival is celebrating its 30th. The festival always had documentaries, but they arrived here and there without being programmed. Tiina Lokk, the festival director, had been thinking for years about how to curate them. We’d even had a short conversation about it two years before I was officially invited. I think it was partly a problem for her, because more and more documentaries were coming and people were bombarding her with emails. Documentary is a different part of this world, and you have to be involved to navigate it.
When she finally decided to launch the competition and asked me, I hesitated. I teach, and I produce and direct as well, and I was thinking like a producer, afraid there would be a great deal to organise, much more than when I make a film. Then it turned out the festival has a well-established team, with devoted people handling travel, guests, or marketing. I was left with the pleasant part, which is thinking about the programme.

How do you divide the work with your team?
There are four of us watching films. The main period is the summer, and that is not the pleasant moment. This is my third summer of watching films every day, and it is a lot. We meet once a week, agree on how many films we will watch before the next meeting, and then discuss them. We use a blind system, so each of us enters comments and suggestions that the others cannot see until we meet. It is quite independent. Sometimes our opinions differ, and sometimes they align. I like this part because we analyse films and have to defend our positions, and I enjoy hearing the others.
If we cannot agree, the last word is mine, provided I am sure the film is good and will work for our audience. A couple of films were mostly my decision.
How do the four of you differ?
Edvinas Pukšta is from Lithuania and also works on other programmes, including fiction. He watches everything and has a day with more hours than anyone else. He is more of a cinephile, and sometimes he thinks less about the audience than I do. Mike Arnott is from the UK and lives in Estonia. His outsider view is interesting, especially on subjects that feel fresh to us locals when he has already seen fifty films about them. Mikk Granström is local, and probably closer to me. Putting the four opinions together creates an interesting synergy, and in the third year I am quite proud of the programme we have assembled.
«Putting the four opinions together creates an interesting synergy»
Were there outside factors behind the decision to start a documentary competition, such as geopolitics or the surge in production after the pandemic?
Outside factors always play a part, because we only have the films that were submitted, and that is our field of selection. We are not a documentary festival, and we do not have an industry platform for documentary. We are working on that, but it does not exist yet. We are also very close to IDFA. We start first, but IDFA starts a little later, and we finish on the same day. Some filmmakers do not consider us their first choice, so they apply to IDFA, and those films never reach us.
This year we lost six films that we had selected for the competition. We had told the filmmakers, and then IDFA picked them, or they were counting on the Berlinale. We probably weren’t attractive enough to them, and that is a reality we have to accept. For the films that do land on our table, we consider how current they are and which themes are active at the moment. We look for artistic expression, a story with an artistic side, because journalistic films usually deal with very immediate events.

Does the Baltic documentary tradition, with its meditative and poetic strain, inform that approach?
I would not say we look specifically for the poetic in the International Competition, although the Baltic one always has many such films. For the international strand, we are open to the artistic, which is a little different from the poetic. Our audience is well prepared for documentaries and far from beginners. Estonian television shows many films, and most Estonian documentaries premiere and get a small but decent run in cinemas. People here are used to more sophisticated, artistic documentaries than in some other parts of the world, and we have to keep that in mind.
Is Estonia’s documentary infrastructure strong enough to sustain that audience?
The financing system is more or less the same as in the Nordic countries. We took the format from Scandinavia, and it works very well, although our level of financing is, let’s say, decent. We also have a problem with the poetic tradition, which is not much appreciated outside the Baltics. That is a real problem for our international reach. I cannot deny it.
How does your approach to the Baltic Competition differ from the International one?
Last year the Baltic programme was very strong. We had more films on the table than we could take, because the festival limits us to eleven. This year was different. We have only nine films, because we did not even have ten that would be valuable for the festival. Several are co-productions where the director is not from the Baltics, and we took them only when a Baltic country’s involvement was significant. The directors from last year are probably working on new projects, and that takes time.

What themes did you see emerging across the Baltic submissions?
I can only speak about what we had. We were looking for good films, but several this year connect to ecology. Several were made in that typically poetic, very beautifully filmed language. I do not know which audience will watch them, but they are beautiful, and one of them deals with the pollution of the Baltic Sea and shows how ruined the seabed is near where we live. There are two films about Ukraine. One is by a Lithuanian director in co-production with Ukraine. The other is by a Ukrainian director, with Lithuanian and Latvian producers, and part of the post-production is done in those countries. We also have two Estonian films, one of them the very poetic The Perfect, about three generations of women in ballet.
We were mostly looking for professionally made films with international market potential. Last year and two years ago, we had one Estonian film in the International Competition each time. This year, they are all in the Baltic programme. A dedicated programme helps films travel. Last year’s film about a famous Estonian clown duo, My Family and Other Clowns, won the Jury Special Prize and has been at several festivals, and a Lithuanian film from two years ago also travelled a lot. The life of a documentary is short. You have one year for the festival run, and if nobody notices you, you are probably seen only in your own country.
«Several were made in that typically poetic, very beautifully filmed language.»
«Balance» is a loaded word in programming. Where does it fall in your International selection?
If two films share a subject, we calculate which country and which film will work better with our audience, because with only eleven films you cannot place the same subject twice. Last year we had three beautiful films about boarding schools for children with special needs, and we had to pick one. I do not think we had that problem this year.
As the programme took shape, I noticed two things. One was the relationship between fathers and their grown-up children. Several films, on absolutely different topics, have that at their centre, and they appear in both the competition and Best of Festivals. Documentaries take years to make, so it is striking that several arrive in the same year. After MeToo, many films were about women, and I think filmmakers now sensed a gap: nobody was talking about men.
The other thing was recreation. I have never been a fan of staged episodes in documentary. If you want to recreate something, make a fiction film with a better cast and better direction. This year was different, and I liked it, which is why I took those films. Before, recreation illustrated something that had already happened when you had no archive. This year, several films, and some of them we could not fit in, use recreation as part of the story and the method, as a way of dealing with reality and playing with it. Every film does it differently. When half our programme was in place, I realised that this film and that film and the next all had a new approach to reality, a new way of making documentaries. Perhaps it comes from my teaching, with new generations arriving, although the filmmakers are not necessarily young.
The argument about what reality is, and whether enactments are allowed, has existed as long as documentary itself. With new media, I think it makes less difference now, and reality has become a kind of playground. Recreation is part of the story and goes beyond illustration.

You are both an academic and a working curator. Do those two parts of your background pull against each other?
I am definitely not struggling with that. I watch films with an open eye and an open heart. I can analyse afterwards, and I think I am good at defending or criticising a film, but that is the next level. First, I have to love the film and feel emotionally attached to the story. I always see the weak moments and where the film could be better, but a documentary is rarely ideal. Something has to touch you, because if you are attached to the emotion, the audience will be too. Then comes the next level: how to package the film, what to write about it, and how to sell it to the audience.
«A documentary is rarely ideal»
The World Congress of Science and Factual Producers is coming to the festival this year. What will your relationship be with it?
The congress came to Tallinn partly because of me. We were looking for a way to start building a documentary industry, and this proposal arrived suddenly. Tiina said yes immediately, although it was probably too early, because public money is planned a year ahead. When we began looking for financing, it became obvious. Still, I hope a new network will form. I plan to talk with several people there, and we already have ideas for next year that I cannot share yet. We want to grow something.
The Baltic Event, the fiction side of our industry programme, is very strong, and PÖFF is what it is largely thanks to it, because the people come for it. Our documentaries screen in the first week, and the cinemas are always quite empty. Last year some of my jury members said what a lovely, calm, tiny festival it was, because they had no idea how big it is and how many people arrive later. It is not enough for a documentary programme just to show films, otherwise, it is only screenings, and that needs additional financing. We are already taking some steps.
When I started as curator and travelled to festivals and pitching sessions as a representative, I met two kinds of people. Some had never been to PÖFF but had heard a lot of positive things and wanted to come, and others had been and wanted to return. It is really a brand, and I want to build something around documentary as well.
The post PÖFF: «I watch films with an open eye and an open heart» appeared first on Modern Times Review.