...

Review of SEEING IS BELIEVING by Peter Biskind.

Since the fall of 1984 A movie in a quarter. I reviewed this book at Biskind’s request, and my position was hampered by the fact that he was the editor-in-chief. American film At a time where his assignments were essential to my livelihood. Our relationship became even more strained after I was already ready to review the book and then he informed me that he wanted me not to review it. – Jr

Seeing Is Believing: How Hollywood Taught Us To Stop Worrying And Love The Fifties By Peter Biskind. new York: Pantheon Books, 1983. $22.95 cloth, $10.95 paper.

The first thing to say about Peter Biskind’s ambitious and long-awaited study of ideology in fifties Hollywood films is that its casual intervention cannot be without considerable confusion. Without the benefit of Biskind’s careful construction and preparation, the unwary reader is mired in many political lines or ambiguities. Labels with which highway of thieves For example, it is indicated as a “right-wing film”, or high noon and Blob as “radical films”. Even in the introduction, which is more cautious than the rest of the book, the following sentence raises a few eyebrows: “Robert Aldrich’s films can usually be somewhere to the left, just as Elia Kazan’s films are often in the middle, and John Ford’s films are to Alfred’s right, his and Hiko’s.”“

Although there is nothing Seeing is believing Succeeding quite successfully in eliminating all the pitfalls contained in the above declaration, the book is far more reasoned and sensible than any kind of scattered spot-checking might suggest. Examining the period that extends “from about Harry Truman’s victory in 1948 to the beginning of the Kennedy presidency in 1960,” Biskind is primarily concerned with the degree to which Hollywood films of this era “represented not one but several militant ideologies, so that one can speak of radical (as well as left-wing and right-wing) films.” Readers A movie in a quarter who have already come across Biskind’s excellent political dissection A rebel without a cause and on the beach In these pages, as an early case study in this enterprise (see the Fall 1974 and Fall 1975 issues, respectively)—both partially adapted in the present book, culled from their original polemical context, but still detailed and compelling—one will be pleased to find it equally poignant. Twelve Angry Men, Them!, The Thing, The Day The Earth Stood Still and broken arrowwith other films, and that he has constructed his analysis in relation to a general system of categories, which makes the main argument of the book reasonable and coherent in relation to his special terms.

For many readers, however, the biggest problem with Biskind’s book is precisely these terms. Biskind relied almost exclusively on American commentators from around the same period to determine what he meant by the ideology of the fifties in relation to concepts such as consensus, dissent, minorities, sex roles and crime. Thus, while neither Marx nor Freud appears in the bis index, David Raisman receives dozens of citations, Daniel Bell and William H. . White, Jr., nine pieces, Arthur Schlesinger, Jr., eight, William F. Buckley, Jr. Six, Lionel Trilling and Robert Warshaw four each and Eric Fromm three. And since all eight of these latter writers are cited mostly as immediate authorities rather than as figures themselves shaped by Pentecostal ideology, the system that Biskind constructs is of necessity quite limited.

In general, the emphasis is on plots rather than aesthetic effects by other means, which in certain cases leads to controversial interpretations. Biskind categorizes Nicholas Ray in a lonely placeAs a conservative film, I see it as a liberal-masochistic one, and the difference between our interpretations has less to do with the plot than with the ambiguity of Humphrey Bogart’s exact role in relation to the plot. (A comparable difference in readings was observed in Biskind’s original treatment A rebel without a cause in in the movie quarter, When he objected to my description of Ray larger than life (as a “deeply disturbing exposure of middle-class aspirations” by treating his protagonist’s behavior as a cautionary warning rather than a problematic site for the audience to identify with.) More generally, as a social/political commentator often troubled by issues of consensus, Biskind is usually only too willing to accept his values ​​where his consensus becomes the standard. No different from a mass audience. When we read that “Resolution red river The shooting that didn’t happen, a good ideology but a bad ending; He was frowned upon by the reviewers of the day and never found favor with the traditionalists”, it seems inevitable to suggest that Biskind aligns his aesthetic reasoning directly with the traditionalists and reviewers of 1948.

To be fair, however, Biskind is quite capable of making acute aesthetic observations that go beyond the scope of status quo consideration. (Had it not been, this book would not have been possible, for however exclusively its focus on trained ideology rather than aesthetics, an understanding of the former invariably requires an understanding of the latter, whether acknowledged or not.) With his excellent treatment The things For example, he gets a lot of interesting runs from Pat Hendry (Kenneth Tobey), who Nicky Nicholson (Margaret Sheridan) playfully ties to a piece of roped ice: “There’s a thing inside the ice, just like a Hendry inside is an ID. Ice that accidentally breaks melts. Just as Hendry avoids Nicky’s bonds.’

To be witty and to the point, Bis kind writes fluid and readable prose, tinged, to my taste, only with an over-reliance on familiar phrases to sum up h.is issues. The problem with this tool is that repetition often leads one to wait impatiently for the other shoe to drop (to hear my catchphrase). After establishing that “women in centric science fiction are either one of the boys or like children” and that invasion body clamps is anti-centrist and adds that in the latter film “women and children come first”. When “one of Hendry’s men (in case) Hitting the revolver in the face, Carrington gathers that the force rises from the barrel of the gun.” After the hero’s idyllic domestic situation great warmth established, we learn that “every utopia must have a little rain.” After an account of a poker game involving Lagana, the villain of the same film, we are told that “Langana’s game is the only game in town.” On the next page, after noting that the protagonist Bannon “intuitively does the right thing,” Biskind couldn’t resist adding, “In his heart, he knows he’s right.” In board jungle, “Dadier has the will, but is there a way?”; For Ethan Edwards seekers, “Better Dead Than Red” sisters.

Some of these pirouettes have interesting and thought-provoking points – these great warmth is the pre-Goldwater that The seekers is a cold war movie – so they can’t be written off as gratuitous. But the fact that Biskind deploys these clichés so often that trivializing the rhythm of his arguments; The purely formalist pleasure in capturing an idea through a catch phrase sometimes overwhelms the power of the idea itself.

Also unfortunate are some glaring factual errors. Except for removing the “d” and adding a “d” to Bud Boetticher’s name” that cat people (unless it’s proofreading errors), Biskind claims to equal Tolly Devlin’s (Cliff Robertson) stunning death walk at the end of Fuller Underworld USA ” opened Godard for a remarkable closing out of breath,” When browsing movie dates makes it impossible; Even less convincingly, we’re told that Norman Bates will appear in “The Last Shot.” Psycho Like her mother, “wig, dress and all,” which misrepresents the final shots of this film as well. (2020 Note: I think this is partly a matter of interpretation; see below.)

More generally, however, Biskind is quite circumspect about the films he describes, and if anyone questions, say, Mercedes McCambridge’s status as a “proto-lesbian.” johnny guitar Or in Angie, in which Angie Dickinson “transforms from call girl to housewife.” Rio Bravo These are more nuanced issues than textual differences. on it is best Seeing is believing Reveals many interesting subtexts for films of the fifties. (I was particularly struck by Delmer Davies’s detailed 1950 description broken arrowA film whose treatment of Indians is uncannily similar to that of South Sea Islanders in Davies’ later film of 1951, bird of paradise After studying the ideology of the latter film moving parts (I was intrigued to find that, as radically different as our methodologies are, Biskind and I came up with essentially the same analysis.) Although juggling terms like “left” and “right” inevitably backs Biskind into certain corners—for example, when he cites one of Jim Stark’s choices.e the end A rebel without a cause As a “left-wing, or perhaps right-wing solution” – their cumulative impact and significance is nevertheless instructive, and some films described, a rebel Between them, it probably won’t look the same anymore.–Jonathan Rosenbaum

Leave a Comment