Martin Short and Selena Gomez stopped by Jimmy Kimmel Live To promote the new season Only murders in the buildingwhich is located in London. But while they discussed the new episodes, Jimmy Kimmel asked Short to revisit a story he told the late-night show in January in which the actress nearly ruined Gomez’s wedding to Benny Blanco.
Kimmel encouraged Short to “wrap up the story” before getting to Gomez’s perspective. “First of all, it’s crazy because I’m innocent in this story,” Short said. “Selena has the most fabulous, beautiful wedding imaginable. And in this one main tent where the after ceremony took place. (There were) 18, 20 musicians, a dance floor and a nightclub.”
He recalled that there were sections with sofas and chairs for groups to sit. “And there was this cake,” he said. “And I just assumed it was a cake for each individual (group). It turned out to be a wedding cake.” Short, who admitted he “might” have been drinking, cut the cake with a fork as Steve Martin left the party. Kimmel then revealed a photo of the mutilated cake.
“I love the fork teeth marks where he was trying to save her,” Gomez said. “Really well done.”
Gomez added that Short “seemed to insist” that no one tell him what happened. “They were able to pull it together,” he said. “And I didn’t care. I was there, but I didn’t know what happened. And then all of a sudden someone comes and they say, ‘Marty cut your cake. And I think he was eating.” I was like, “Oh!” So I’m running and he’s like a little dog with his tail between his legs. I’m going, I heard you eat my cake.
Gomez explained that the cake was not meant for all the guests, but as a moment for her and Blanco. It became a moment for him, Blanco and Short. “We’ll always have that memory together and honestly, I’ll never forget it,” he said.
Gomez and Blanco got married last September. The couple got engaged in December 2024 after more than a year of dating. The wedding was attended by many famous people, including Taylor Swift, who gave a speech. Short and Martin attended for a long time along with other actors Only murders in the building. Short recalled turning to Paul Rudd after the cake incident and asking, “Should we go?”
New season Only murders in the building Premieres December 8 on Hulu.