As “Doctor Who” fans (aka Whovians) no doubt know, the show is a bit of a drag. Since its debut in 1963, the series has maintained a clever sci-fi concept that allowed multiple actors to canonically play the title role of the Doctor. The character, you see, is a time-traveling alien known as a Time Lord, and when they die, they manage to regenerate into a new person. Each time the Doctor regenerates, their personality changes slightly, although they still have the same memories, intelligence and enthusiasm.
Unfortunately, after running for so long, Doctor Who has developed a bad habit of falling back on old tropes. My friend Viniel agreed that Doctor Who is in bad shape right now and the future of the franchise is uncertain due to Disney ending its partnership with the show due to low viewership. As my friend said, the series is really in a “boiling” place and no one knows where it will go next.
However, Peter Capaldi has a few suggestions. The actor, who played the Twelfth Doctor from 2014 to 2017, shared his thoughts on his latest appearance on the Half a Picture podcast, explaining that he thinks the show needs to go back to basics. He added that it would be nice to reinvent himself, go back to his low-budget roots and bring back the badass charm of his early days.
Peter Capaldi is at his best in Doctor Who when he experiences a “wave” from his past
In the same interview, Peter Capaldi explained that he’s fine with not being associated with Doctor Who anymore because there are other ventures he’d like to pursue. “Doctor Who,” he noted, is the kind of show that takes over your life, adding, “You can’t do that (…) as a part-time role.” When it comes to the future of the property, Capaldi is tight-lipped, stating:
“What it should be, I don’t know. I was thinking about it (…) I don’t know what they want from it. Because my love for the show was the old show. That’s what I grew up with. And it doesn’t work for me. I can’t come in and say, ‘Let’s set it in the ’60s.’ Let’s make it black and make it cheaper”. Or with less ambition.’ I mean, ‘Doctor Who’ always had ambition, it’s just that the budgets didn’t always support it.”
Capaldi then wondered aloud whether audiences wanted “David and Kyle.” He was, of course, referring to David Tennant’s hugely popular iteration of the Doctor, who appeared alongside Kylie Minogue’s character in Doctor Who’s 2007 Christmas special Voyage of the Damned (which drew impressive audiences). Or maybe they’re more interested in former Doctor Who stars like Christopher Eccleston or Jodie Whittaker. Basically, Capaldi is very unclear about what fans want from the series.
All he can say is that he enjoys “Doctor Who” the most when he experiences what he calls “the Ripples” from the old show. Not necessarily a recycled monster, but a specific tone that sometimes breaks. Something humble and old-fashioned.
Peter Capaldi feels that Doctor Who works best as a “small” show
Although Doctor Who is a time-travel series involving aliens, monsters, major historical figures and untold, world-ending technology, Peter Capaldi feels it’s actually a “small” show. It’s about a small group of characters and their time-traveling TARDIS, which looks like a police box that, thanks to advanced technology, is bigger on the inside than it is on the outside. Capaldi added that if the series could focus on those basics, he could sing again, explaining:
“It’s the Doctor and the assistant-slash-assistants in the TARDIS. Pretty disruptive. Do the embalming. And like ‘The Lion, the Witch and the Wardrobe,’ they walk through the gates of this drama. And these dramas change shape and have monsters in them. Magical, weird, weird, sad people at the center.
I’ve personally watched enough of the show to know that most of the best Doctor Who episodes embody what Capaldi was talking about. The problem is that many of the series’ season-long storylines culminate with some sort of supervillain threatening to destroy the world, undo history, or commit some other massive sci-fi cataclysm. And if these types of cataclysms happen on a regular basis, then it’s no wonder that fans are feeling jaded (or that the show’s creatives might be running out of ideas).
Time will tell if the minds behind Doctor Who take Capaldi’s advice and recast the series in a cheaper, more humble form. It certainly doesn’t hurt that the series was canceled after a short-lived Disney run and a planned 2026 Christmas special. Capaldi might just be on to something.