...

Speak No Evil (2024) Review (Remake – Now on Netflix)

Technology is incredibly advanced, but emotionally speaking, we are all still cavemen. It’s all the perfect life, Instagram, Facebook bullshit. everyone is talking But no one is honest.“

Calm down! This Speak No Evil (2024) review is spoiler free.

Critics tend to have a pretty big bee in their collective when it comes to Western remakes of non-English language horror films – and usually for good reason.

Think of the inane The Uninvited (2009), for example—Hollywood’s attempt to replicate the singularly disturbing cinematic experience that was South Korea’s “Tale of Two Sisters”—or similar disruptions of their time, such as One Missed Call (2008) or Japan’s The Eye (2008): Hong Kong-Singaporean Jin Gwai (2002), respectively. Even more recently, 2015’s Martyrs—which lacked the philosophical, polarizing portrait so vaguely painted in the 2008 French original—showed that overseas magic The horror of endurance Western lenses are even more difficult to adapt or replicate.

I say this because on paper Speak No Evil (2024) is a remake of Christian Tafdrup’s 2022 Danish film. guestswhich is translated literally and more correctly as guests – Shouldn’t have worked. Released just two years after its source material, you could be forgiven for thinking it has all the hallmarks of a rushed Hollywood production of a movie: seen, compared unfavorably to the original, and ultimately, inevitably, forgotten.

But guess what? Speak No Evil (2024) is brilliant.

Here it is: your average American family meets another family (in this case, British) on vacation and forms the kind of awkward, opportunistic friendship that’s meant to last for a few days before fading into nothingness when everyone gets on their flights home. In the case of Speak No Evil, our American protagonists are the Daltons: parents Ben (Scoot McNair), Louise (Mackenzie Davis), and daughter Agnes (Alix West Leffler). While lounging by the pool, they cross paths with brash and bombastic—but strangely, perversely charming—sidekicks: Paddy (a wonderfully good James McAvoy) and Chiara (Aisling Francios, in 2023). The Last Voyage of Demetrius) and their son Ant (Dan Huff). Paddy explains that Ant has a condition in which he was born with a tongue too small for his mouth and is unable to speak beyond occasional guttural, animal sounds.

The Fields are the archetype of the annoying couple on vacation. (And the fact that they’re British was a sly and definitely deliberate decision. Openly mocking some of the family’s dry – but friendly – ​​hotel guests; loud drunks by the pool.

But Paddy’s charisma and Ciara’s humbler, kinder nature make a good match, and the Daltons – mainly Ben – are drawn to them. They share meals and make vague plans for when they return to the UK. (The Daltons live in London after Ben has been transferred there for work; the Fields are based deep in the Devonshire countryside.) Again, it’s the kind of invitation that feels serious and capable at the time – but almost always falls apart when passports are stamped and the house is set up.

But. but, Fields delivers a postcard – emblazoned with a picture of the two families on vacation – and secures an invitation. Louise refuses, but Ben persists, and they travel to Fields’ secluded country house in the middle of nowhere.

Saxon's Lode Manor House near Malvern Hills, Worcestershire, where scenes were filmed in Speak No Evil (2024)

Scenes involving Fields House, located in Devonshire, in Speak No Evil (2024) were filmed at Saxon’s Lode Manor House near the Malvern Hills in Worcestershire.

At first glance, it all looks idyllic—just as I imagine most Americans probably think of England when they dream of quixotic trips to its green fields and beautiful scenery of barns and rolling meadows. but – But – Everything would not be as it seemed at first. The Daltons are increasingly annoyed by their hosts’ strange, passive-aggressive behavior towards them and each other, and the star of the show – Scottish actor James McAvoy.

James McAvoy as Paddy and Scoot McNairy as Ben in Speak No Evil (2024) Hunt in the Woods

Paddy (James McAvoy) and Ben (Scoot McNair) go hunting.

Superlatives don’t do justice to how good it is here. He plays Paddy with glee and aggression; Balancing comedy with cool, calculated menace. (Of course, this is all based on a large part of the guy — he clearly hasn’t lost the weight he gained for 2016’s Split , and Wesley Gibson’s lean, jaded corporate drone in 2008’s Wanted is a distant memory. Stands on hills and screams into the void to relieve stress. Still kind of envious, kind of weird.Even when Louise admits to Ben that she finds them uncomfortable, Fields’ increasingly disturbing eccentricities still have this weird, sticky charisma to them.

Mackenzie Davis as Louis in Speak No Evil (2024)

Mackenzie Davis as Louis in Speak No Evil (2024)

Other things start to rub off on the Daltons. An ant sleeping in the room with Agnes reveals to her the bruises on her body; Ciara is also black and blue. Paddy berates and abuses the ant, but—more importantly—this abuse is only gradually revealed to the Daltons (and us). Much of the destructive behavior in the Fields that they (and we) observe is unacceptable, dishonest, but the point is that it simply becomes too uncomfortable for the Daltons to leave. Here, the Speak No Evil remake — just as its predecessor did — gleefully plays with the rules of social engagement and the surprising lengths we humans will go to avoid social favoritism. to be polite. The Daltons just can’t bring themselves to cross those fine lines that govern when we draw a line – and so by then they do it Draw that line, fields have taken things to a whole new level.

Scoot McNair as Ben and James McAvoy as Paddy in Speak No Evil (2024) Scream at the Clouds

James McAvoy’s performance as Paddy is the foundation Speak No Evil (2024) is based on.

Still, Speak No Evil works well until something happens later. It works primarily with those awkward exchanges, those jarring dynamics, those social situations gone wrong.

We also learn that there’s another level to the Daltons’ reluctance to call—that they’re working through the interpersonal trauma of their own relationship, damaged by betrayal and a lack of open, honest communication that manifests itself in searing, painful resentment. For them, this holiday wasn’t just a weekend getaway—it was a chance to get things right. It was representative of their battered, battered marriage; A chance to prove that there was something, maybe something.

And that makes what follows even more chilling.

Agnes (Alix West Leffler) in the film

Agnes (Alix West Leffler) makes a disturbing discovery in Seek No Evil (2024).

I don’t want to go any further here at the risk of spoiling anything important. I got into this cold, just like I did the 2022 remake of Goodnight Mommy (another western adaptation of the non-English original that I haven’t seen), and it made all the difference.

I’m generalizing here, but it seems like we cinephiles don’t do it enough anymore—to go cold, with the bare minimum knowledge of the plot or setting—and that’s a shame.

Goodnight Mommy (despite its fair share of dry reviews) was excellent.

Speak No Evil (2024) is even better.

Speak No Evil is available to watch now on Netflix in Australia. Get over it!

Oh, and if you’re wondering if there is are Any good western remake of a foreign horror film is good news – there is! bad news There are only three:

  • Let Me In (2010) – remake of 2008’s Let the Right One In (Sweden)

  • The Ring (2002) – Japanese remake of Ringu (1998)

  • Quarantine (2008) – remake of 2007 (REC) from Spain

Just kidding – more than three! Want to leave your favorite in the comments?

And if you enjoyed this Speak No Evil (2024) review, remember: Talking Terror is your place for the latest and greatest vintage horror movies. Seriously – I’ve covered movies that are just as old Black Sabbath (1963) and I Drink Your Blood (1971)Just like newbies like it Terrifier 3 (2024) and MadS (2024). I’m just a one-man band at this point, so it takes me a while to look things up every now and then – but if there’s a horror movie burning a hole in your pocket and you’re desperate for a new review of it, then let me know. I will do everything!

Leave a Comment